Independent website concept prepared for review. This is not the official Proper Pie Co. website.

Eat your pie.

New Zealand-style savory pies, sausage rolls, and deep-dish sweet pies, baked fresh every day on East Broad Street in Church Hill.

Checking the case

— savory pies— sweet slices

Three savory hand pies cut in half and stacked on a wooden board, showing flaky crust and fillings

Mince & Cheese

Beef & lamb$8.9513 left

1 of 20

What’s in the case

Checking the shop’s register…

The badge color tells you the filling. Tap any pie for the details and to order it.

Filter by filling

How a pie day works

Everything is day-of. Pies are baked that morning, sold until they’re gone, and taken off the list the moment someone buys one.

9 am10noon46 pm
The shop is closed right now. Pie days are Wednesday to Sunday.
  1. Every pie is made that day. Nothing carries over.

  2. It’s posted on Instagram, and the case on this page updates itself from the register.

  3. Online orders open for same-day pickup. Pies come off the list the moment they’re bought.

  4. Pick up your order or order at the window. Everything’s ready to go, so it’s quick.

  5. Can’t make pickup? Tell us by 4 so we can sell your pie to someone else. We close at 6, or when we sell out.

Three of the Proper Pie crew in the kitchen, arms up, holding signs that read “You guys love pie so much that we have sold out!!! See you tomorrow! We love ya, RVA!”

Some days, this sign goes up early.

You guys love pie so much that we have sold out!!!See you tomorrow!

When the case empties, it’s empty. Order online from 10 am to hold yours, or come by the window after noon and take your chances.

Order ahead for today
A tall slice of cream-topped pie on a white plate with a black rim

Order Thanksgiving pies ahead.

Whole 9-inch deep-dish pies are $44 each on the everyday menu. Thanksgiving pre-orders open online Tuesday, October 13, at 10 am.

––days
––hours
––minutes
––seconds
Order a whole pie for this week

Whole pies on the menu

  • BanoffeeSold out
  • Buttermilk & RaspberryLast one
  • Chocolate Raspberry Cream2 left
  • Coconut “Cream”Last one
  • Dutch AppleSold out
  • Key LimeSold out
  • Lemon ChessLast one
  • Maple PecanLast one
  • Mississippi MudSold out
  • Pear & Almond TartLast one
  • Sour Cream & Wild Blueberry StreuselSold out
  • Strawberry RhubarbSold out

A kiwi pie shop in Church Hill.

Neil Smith grew up in Whangārei, New Zealand, where a good pie is sold everywhere from corner shops to gas stations. He cooked in Michelin-starred kitchens in London, then spent nearly a decade as a touring chef, feeding David Bowie, Madonna, Beyoncé, Paul McCartney, and their crews.

On a Nine Inch Nails tour he met Nikki Price, a VCU graduate and Richmond caterer. Neil couldn’t find a proper pie in the States, so in 2012 they started making them here.

The savory pies are five-inch, handheld, and always include beef, chicken, pork, vegetarian, and vegan options, plus a fish or lamb pie that rotates every couple of weeks. Sweet pies change with the seasons.

A crimped hand pie on a white plate, with a second pie broken open to show a beef and vegetable filling

Kiwi at the counter

Mince
Ground beef. Mince and cheese is the classic kiwi pie.
Sweet as
Kiwi for “great.” It’s also our shelf of cookies and extras.
Anzac biscuit
A crunchy oat and coconut cookie made with golden syrup.
Cuppa
A hot tea. Ours is PG Tips.
The PieHole
Our pickup window on East Broad Street.
Three white Proper Pie Pi Day mugs stamped 3.14.24, stacked against gold glitter
A new mug every Pi Day, March 14.

Come to the PieHole.

2505 E Broad St, Suite 100
Richmond, VA 23223
Wednesday
noon to 6 pm
Thursday
noon to 6 pm
Friday
noon to 6 pm
Saturday
noon to 6 pm
Sunday
noon to 6 pm
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
Closed

To drink: a cuppa, iced coffee from our friends at Blanchard’s, Bundaberg ginger beer, and Mexican Coke. A 24-ounce cup of ice water to go is fifty cents.

Hands raising Proper Pie pint glasses in front of the shop’s mint-green shelves and big PIE letters